History in the News – ‘A gift for Holocaust deniers’: how Polish libel ruling will hit historians. Something to discuss in History Society…

If you click here you will get to an article in The Guardian by Jo Glanville. It comments on reports a that the authors of a study on the fate of Polish Jews under Nazism have been told to apologise to a woman for defaming her uncle.

“In Night Without End, a forensic two-volume history that totals nearly 1,700 pages, professors Barbara Engelking and Jan Grabowski focus on the fate of Jews in Nazi-occupied Poland after the Nazis began liquidating the ghettoes in 1942. The book includes a brief passage based on the testimony of a survivor, Estera Siemiatycka, who accused Edward Malinowski, a village elder in Malinowo, north-east Poland, of collaborating with the Nazis and denouncing a group of Jews in hiding.

Malinowski’s niece, 81-year-old Filomena Leszczyńska, sued the historians. The Polish League Against Defamation financed the case, claiming in a lengthy statement that the historians had damaged “the reputation not only of Edward Malinowski, but also other Poles, or even Poland” and accused them of “careless use of historical sources”. The League is a handmaiden to Poland’s ruling Law and Justice Party’s political agenda to burnish the country’s wartime​ ​image. With the mission “to initiate and support actions aimed at correcting false information on Poland’s history”, the League has pursued cases against those accused of defaming Poland, including international media outlets.

Copies of the Polish edition of Night Without End on sale at the Jewish Historical Institute in Warsaw.
Copies of the Polish edition of Night Without End on sale at the Jewish Historical Institute in Warsaw. Photograph: Czarek Sokołowski/AP

The Law and Justice Party’s crusade to promote Poland’s heroism under Nazi occupation and end what it calls “the pedagogy of shame” attracted an international outcry three years ago, when it passed legislation outlawing discussion of Polish responsibility in the Holocaust.”

Something to discuss in History Society.

  • Why is history being re-written here?
  • Does this happened in Britain?
  • Are we better at noticing this in other countries? If so why?

Mr Kydd.

Posted in Enrichment, history in the news, Uncategorized | Comments Off on History in the News – ‘A gift for Holocaust deniers’: how Polish libel ruling will hit historians. Something to discuss in History Society…

Something for Holocaust Memorial Day 2021 – Eva Kor – the Holocaust twin who forgave the Nazis

Eva KorAll,

To mark Holocaust Memorial Day I have put some links to the experience of the remarkable Eva Kor (1934 – 2019). The links below speak for themselves, however I would just make the point that sometimes, when deals with a topic a huge as the Holocaust, it is easier to understand what happened by looking a the life of one person. Her forgiveness should be an inspiration to us all.

You may also like to click here read Eva Waite-Taylor’s review of “Night’ by Elie Wiesel in The Independent.

Mr Kydd

Posted in history in the news | Comments Off on Something for Holocaust Memorial Day 2021 – Eva Kor – the Holocaust twin who forgave the Nazis

Oxbridge preparation – reading something different – Best books of 2020: History

downloadIn normal times I would be advising those of you thinking of history / Oxbridge applications to start visiting places like the British Museum, and reading something completely beyond your A level topics. Only the latter is on the cards for the foreseeable future, so you might like to click here. This is Tony Barber’s recommendations from 2020. If you don’t know where to start, may I suggest Afinogenov’s Spies and Scholars

Review below…

“Superb…At once a history of science, of empire, and of espionage, the book traces the rise of the Russian empire as a putative rival to Qing dynasty China in the Far East. Afinogenov has chosen a genuinely compelling cast of characters to populate this story of imperial intrigue…A vividly written, entertaining, and skilfully researched history…”

Mr Kydd.

Posted in Book Reviews | Comments Off on Oxbridge preparation – reading something different – Best books of 2020: History

History Society – something to discuss – Cultural warriors attacking ‘woke’ history care little for truth. It’s all political theatre David Olusoga

10661If you click here you will get to a  sharp article in Sunday’s Observer by David Olusoga. I have included an extract below. Have a read and see what you think…

“In both the US and the UK, these new history wars have the warped logic of a witch trial. Their aim is to convince people that they are being oppressed by the irrefutable facts of their own national histories. Shared histories, such as US slavery or the British empire, are presented as alien narratives, introduced by outsiders in order to pollute the pure waters of “Our History”.

Like men with a guilty conscience, those promoting these history wars accuse others of the crime they are committing, because it is not historians but politicians who are fomenting divisions. This is why Jenrick’s statue wars article was loaded with trigger words – “mobs”, “woke” and “militants”.

The defenders of “Our History” and the promoters of “patriotic education” understand that their vision of the past is simplistic, reductive and ahistorical. Their aim, in both the UK and the US, is to pander to notions of exceptionalism that have for so long prevented us from confronting difficult facts and painful truths about what our nations have done and been and how those histories continue to shape our modern societies.”

I would be very interested to know what you think about this view.

Mr Kydd.

Posted in Enrichment, historians, History Society | Comments Off on History Society – something to discuss – Cultural warriors attacking ‘woke’ history care little for truth. It’s all political theatre David Olusoga

History Society – Something to discuss – What will Trump’s legacy be?

TrumpIf you click here you will get to a BBC article where US historians debate Donald Trump’s legacy. This is a useful article for us. By contrasting different historians back-to-back it makes the point very clearly that you conclusions often depend on your starting point. It is also noteworthy what they emphasise and what they downplay.

Have a read, and we can discuss this. Above all- which do you agree with more – and why?

Mr Kydd.

Posted in Enrichment, historians, History Society, Politics | Comments Off on History Society – Something to discuss – What will Trump’s legacy be?

Enrichment – Queen Mary’s Geoview project – data visualisation sheds new light on Britain’s Tudor past

If you click here you will get to an excellent new project from Queen Mary University – London. It’s aim is to analyse and visualise communication networks from Tudor times.

“Tudor Networks works in a similar way to platforms such as Google Maps. It offers to possibility for users to view almost 100 years of history from a macro perspective. Just like Google Maps might reveal streets that had never been mapped before, this platform reveals hidden histories and network connections that were previously unknown.

The platform allows users to zoom in and out of correspondence, jump from one point in history to the next, move from a view of thousands letters to the itineraries of a specific person, and to view the networked connections of people through time, and to read various letters related to this. 

The data visualisation website of the project maps over 120,000 letters pertaining to the Tudor government, which are part of the State Papers, many of which are held by the National Archives. The collection includes political missives, foreign intelligence reports from diplomats and spies, as well as correspondence intercepted through the practices of espionage.”

It is very clever – have a look.

Mr Kydd

Posted in Enrichment | Comments Off on Enrichment – Queen Mary’s Geoview project – data visualisation sheds new light on Britain’s Tudor past

Pulling Black History Month together

We are currently pulling together all the lower school entries for who they would put on a statue (and why). We are going to make a display of them in the department. Look out for it – some really are excellent. I thought I would include for you guys three enrichment opportunities that you might like to explore.

  1. A new 20 minute documentary on the Central Club Mural (and the attempts to save it) – below
  2. All the Black History Month tagged stories from Sky news
  3. All the BBC World Service witness reports

I hope that there is something here to interest you.

Mr kydd

Posted in Enrichment | Comments Off on Pulling Black History Month together

Two significant anniversaries this week

Real-Poppies-80770All,

Obviously this is the end of Remembrance week. It does however mark two significant anniversaries. You may have noted in the news that Wednesday marked the centenary of the laying to rest of the unknown soldier in Westminster Abbey. Less reported is the fact that Saturday marks the eightieth anniversary of the bombing of Coventry. This was amongst the very worst of the Blitz.

Below are two excellent pieces of journalism from the BBC. The first is Dan Snow on the story of the unknown soldier. Below that is a link to the BBC’s 70 stories website. This is a remarkable piece of oral history done in 2010 to record the scale and impact of that bombing by the people who lived through it.

Both are humbling and worth your time.

BBC – 70 Stories for 70 Years

Mr Kydd.

Posted in Enrichment | Comments Off on Two significant anniversaries this week

Enrichment – something to discuss – What came after the Spanish Flu?

Posted in Enrichment | Comments Off on Enrichment – something to discuss – What came after the Spanish Flu?

Enrichment – something to discuss – the battle over what US children learn about American history

p08t3y1gAs President Trump pushes for “patriotic education” in American schools, some teachers say students aren’t being taught the whole story when it comes to US history and its roots with slavery.

Click here for a BBC video report.

Mr Kydd

Posted in Enrichment, History Society | Comments Off on Enrichment – something to discuss – the battle over what US children learn about American history